The Alumni Director’s Dilemma

The Alumni Director’s Dilemma

Sarah had been running her university’s alumni association for five years. Every year, she faced the same challenges: dwindling event attendance, open rates on emails slipping lower, and members asking, “What do I really get from being part of this?”

She tried everything — mixers, newsletters, mentorship programs. They helped, but they didn’t answer the bigger question: how do we provide something that truly matters to members long after graduation?

Then, she discovered a way to offer a benefit her members would never forget.

A Story of True Value

When one of Sarah’s alumni, David, was ready to buy his first home, he turned to the program she had put in place. Instead of feeling overwhelmed and alone, David had access to a personal concierge who walked him through the process, connected him with trusted partners, and unlocked exclusive savings on services he actually needed.

For David, this wasn’t just another perk. It was the difference between feeling lost and feeling supported. And when he got the keys to his first home, he didn’t just celebrate with his family — he told everyone how his alumni association had been there for him in a life-changing way.

Why It Worked

  • It created true value. Not just discounts, but meaningful support at a critical moment in life.

  • It built loyalty. David now sees the alumni association as a lifelong partner, not just a group he left behind after graduation.

  • It cost Sarah’s association nothing. The program was structured so her team simply offered access — and the rest was handled seamlessly.

From Nostalgia to Relevance

Sarah’s alumni association no longer had to fight for attention in crowded inboxes or hope members showed up once a year. She had positioned the group as a modern, relevant organization that delivered life-changing value.

And that’s the shift every alumni leader dreams about.

👉 If you’re ready to make your association more than just a memory, let’s talk. Schedule a call with me today and see how this exclusive program can change the way your members see you — forever.

💡 Check out our other blogs for more insights.

Giving Members the Kind of Value They’ll Never Forget

From Hustle to Legacy—How Realtors Can Actually Pass Down Wealth

Why Your Current Brokerage Won’t Protect Your Future

We’re Expanding! Join the Shaina McAndrews Team in Pennsylvania