Selling In Fishtown In 2025: What The Numbers Say And Why The Shaina McAndrews Team Is A Smart Listing Partner
Fishtown remains one of Philadelphia’s most talked‑about neighborhoods, with a mix of trendy restaurants, art spaces, and renovated rowhomes drawing buyers from across the region. In 2025, the market has cooled from the peak frenzy, but values remain high and well‑presented homes are still selling—making this a strategic, not automatic, seller’s market.
How Fishtown prices and demand look in 2025
On one major portal, the median listing home price in Fishtown in September 2025 is just under 490,000 dollars, up about 8.8% year over year, with a listing price per square foot around 290 dollars. The median sold price, however, is lower—around 349,000 dollars—which shows that while sellers are listing high, buyers are negotiating based on recent sales and value.
Additional data shows the median sale price of a Fishtown home around 370,000 dollars in late 2025, down roughly 3–10% compared with the prior year depending on the month, with homes taking about 57–60 days on average to sell. That means Fishtown is still more expensive and slower‑moving than many parts of the city, but remains a prime target for buyers who want a vibrant neighborhood close to Center City.
What this means for Fishtown sellers
Market reports describe Fishtown as “somewhat competitive” in 2025, with more inventory and slightly longer days on market compared with the most frenzied years but ongoing strong demand for updated rowhomes and move‑in‑ready properties. A recent neighborhood‑level analysis notes that average list prices are higher than the five‑year average, while average sale prices are somewhat lower, suggesting that pricing strategy and patience are crucial for sellers.
Citywide forecasts still call for moderate price appreciation of roughly 2.5–4.5% into 2026, and Fishtown continues to appear on lists of neighborhoods with strong buyer interest thanks to its lifestyle appeal and ongoing development. For sellers, this means there is real opportunity—but only when the home is properly prepared and priced in line with what buyers are actually paying today, not just what neighbors listed for.
Why many Fishtown sellers rely on the Shaina McAndrews Team
The Shaina McAndrews Team at eXp Realty has a strong reputation for helping sellers succeed in fast‑changing, trend‑driven neighborhoods like Fishtown where lifestyle and design matter as much as square footage. Shaina’s online profiles on major real estate platforms highlight excellent reviews, strong client satisfaction, and a track record of results, emphasizing her responsiveness, market knowledge, and negotiation skills.
Local branding and content describe Shaina as one of the region’s best agents for homeowners who want a high‑touch, marketing‑forward listing experience rather than a basic “put it on the MLS and hope” approach. That approach is particularly valuable in a neighborhood like Fishtown, where the right photos, staging, and storytelling can make the difference between average interest and multiple offers.
How the Shaina McAndrews Team would market your Fishtown home
When you list a Fishtown home with the Shaina McAndrews Team, the process begins with a detailed analysis of recent Fishtown sales, active competition, and buyer trends to set a realistic pricing range that balances ambition with market reality. The team then provides clear guidance on prepping your home—often focusing on paint, lighting, decluttering, and small design touches that match Fishtown’s modern‑industrial aesthetic buyers love.
On launch, your listing benefits from professional photography and video, compelling descriptions that highlight both the home and the Fishtown lifestyle, and targeted digital marketing aimed at buyers specifically searching for Fishtown and nearby neighborhoods. The team actively manages showings, gathers feedback, and negotiates offers, helping you handle counteroffers and inspection requests in a way that protects your bottom line while keeping the deal moving.
Is 2025 a good time to sell your Fishtown home?
Even with some softening in sale prices compared with peak highs, Fishtown remains one of Philadelphia’s higher‑value, high‑interest neighborhoods, with buyers still drawn to its amenities, character, and location. For long‑time owners and early buyers, that means a chance to lock in significant gains, especially if you time your listing well and present your home in the best possible light.
If you are considering selling a home, condo, or small multi‑family property in Fishtown, reach out to the Shaina McAndrews Team at eXp Realty. With strong reviews, deep regional expertise, and a proven system for marketing homes in trend‑driven neighborhoods, they are a powerful choice to be your listing agents and help you navigate the 2025 Fishtown market with confidence.
